I can't remember if that's a "liar" response, a "murderer" response or maybe both, but try just saying the most important fact in simple language. (Make a direct accusation.)Thanks for the tip! Love the game btw.
I know how to convince Lug she is a murderer and a witch, but I can't figure this lying thing out. I noticed that the queen's and Lug's story for how the orc king died are different, not sure how to point it out though. Maybe that's not it..
I'll admit I don't actually have a walkthrough in front of me, but I believe there was one earlier in this thread, if you want more explicit clues.